Sunday, July 22, 2007

Paranoia

I don't understand why someone in this class would feel paranoid. What Tim's trying to do is make us think outside of the little boxes we all live in, to think of how we're influenced and by how much. I don't think he's suggesting that our lives are just like Winston's, but that to some degree they may be similar. He's trying to make us aware of how easily the majority can be manipulated so that we always question authority before just accepting it.
If this was a ploy to get us to relate to Winston's situation, I think it had the desired affect.
Now... on to the comment that I have on 1984. So, after Winston's realization that he and Julia have suppressed their feelings for so long (because of BB) that they are incapable of human emotion, he and Julia talk about how when they are captured and tortured nothing could get in the way of their love. This is not even believable; they'd totally sell each other out to try to save themselves... they don't even know what love is! What do you think will happen next??... Now that they have been captured.
Will they be tortured? Will they come back briefly as Rutherford had?
I don't think they stand a chance against the thought police; they've already been brainwashed to the core, they'd be easy to break in interrogations. In other words... they're doomed!

2 comments:

Kayte said...

I think they've both agreed that it's inevitable that they'll confess to everything. They didn't seem to be concerned with that, or even consider it a betrayal of their feelings for each other. Winston was saying how the only betrayal would be if they could make him stop loving Julia. And that could be some horrible, ominous foreshadowing, but I agreed with their opinion that that was something that even the Thought Police couldn't do.

Melody said...

About what Emily said about our lives being like Winstons: I don't think we're living Winston's life as much as we're living Julia's. Julia has a kind of "What's the big deal, what's the point" apathy that I see in myself and others our age towards "wasting" time and energy to understand what's really going on. The whole part where Winston is trying to impress upon Julia the importance of differentiating truth from lies reminded me of Tim talking to us in class...

"In a way, the worldview of the Party imposed itself most successfully on people incapable of understanding it. They could be made to accept the most flagrant violations of reality, because they never fully grasped the enormity of what was demanded of them, and were not sufficiently interested in public events to notice what was happening" (160).